On Weds. we had a discussion with the new girl in the office about the school voucher system that got defeated last year. She was under the impression that in addition to what she was paying in taxes for public schools we would also be paying for private schools also. When we understood what she thought, we helped set her straight and now she understands the advantage of having the voucher system.
When I was in college, I did a paper on the benefits of the private schools system and the voucher systems. I cannot believe the lack of understanding on this issue. So, I want to write an article and hopefully help at least a couple of people understand the benefits of these issues. While I was in High School, I worked at West Bountiful Elementary as a janitor. Being in such a job along with being a child of the public school system, I have first hand experience in many of the faults of this system.
First off lets define the difference between "public" and "private" and how they work.
When we talk of "public" this term is usually used when referring to anything that is funded by the government. These can vary, from public schools, public library, to even public services. These divisions all receive their money from taxes from the people. From an economic point of view, these types of institutions aren't as efficient as a "private" institution because they don't have the competition to constantly be improving. This is similar to a communistic society, in that once a type of bike is made. Why improve on it? What do I get for creating something better than the previous one? I can't get paid more than the next guy, and I can't be shown any favoritism. So, we are stuck with the ugly grey bike, even though there are better ways of making it. Think of it, no matter whether you have a better education, or your methods are better, you get paid the same as the next guy that does the bare minimum. These places also are allotted a budget that is not based on performance, but on what the government sees that they need.
Now, "private" means that it is not owned and operated by the government, but by a group or individual that is usually interested in providing a product or service. Now, because these people have to compete with the others trying to provide what they also do, there is a different picture. These companies have to be able to provide the best product they can to attract as many buyers as they can to purchase their product and a reasonable price and still have money enough to pay their employees. This means if an employee finds a better way of making a bike or a new design to attract customers, then the company makes more money and therefore can pay this guy more. While the guy that is just doing the minimum won't last long. When anyone needs to be fired, that guy will be the first to go. But, if a company just stays with a design or a way of doing things and doesn't compete, they will surely fail as a business.
Having said this, these two descriptions apply to the school system. Let me share some personal examples of how our public school system works.
In my brother Jared's 3rd Grade year of Elementary School at Woods Cross Elementary, he had a teacher, Ms. Sebastian, who was going through a divorce and was taking her problems with her to school and taking a lot of her frustrations out on the children. One day my brother came home from school very distraught about the day and come to find out this teacher had yelled at the kids because she was frustrated with her husband who had just had flowers delivered to her room. She began to tell the girls how horrible boys are and just made the kid's lives miserable.
When my mother found this out, she approached the principle about the issue and was hoping there was something they could do. The principal, Mr. Terry, was aware of the issue and said there was nothing he could do. He said that they couldn't move my brother out of the class, he couldn't get rid of the teacher, because she couldn't be fired, that takes years. But he could have gotten her out of that school, but she would just move to another school, and he wasn't going to do that. So, basically, my mom and my brother just had to put up with her.
I have shared a story in a previous post about my English teacher my senior year. Again, many of these teachers are not even doing the bare minimum of giving the children entrusted them the education they require. But, because there is so much red tape to get these teachers fired or even repremanded, these teachers can get away with anything.
Now, on a positive note. Jared and I both worked at West Bountiful Elementary as janitors. There was a teacher while we were there that we know cared about her kids. When school was over and after all the other teachers were gone, here this teacher sat, working away on preparing for the next day. We, the janitors, would leave the school at 7:00 and here she stayed longer that we did. Now I know she has the true meaning of caring for her children, but why should she get paid the same amount as Jared's 3rd Grade teacher? She is doing so much more for her kids than my brother's teacher or even my teacher, I want her making more.
This is where private schools and the voucher system comes in. Here is how we get everyone on equal playing grounds. Right now, I being a property owner, am paying for the public education system, now if I want to send my child to private school, I will pay for their public education and their private education. So, I'm getting hit twice here. What the voucher system does is take that money that would have been spent on my child in public school and allows me to take that to a private school of my choice. This doesn't mean that if I want a $15,000 education for my child everyone is flipping the bill, but what it means is the voucher is good for $5,000 and I will have to pay the difference. Now doesn't that seem fair? But wait, this isn't the only benefit!
In introducing these vouchers, it makes it so the public schools and the private schools play on an even playing field. Now, because parents can make an easier choice on where their child goes to school and its not just the local Elementary school, the public schools have to start to compete for students from the private schools. Now, if there was a movement of students from the public schools to the private schools, the public schools will be able to have smaller classroom sizes like they want. Then if the movement is big enough, the allotment of money to each school will begin to decrease, now this sounds bad, but what this does is force the schools to become more efficient, there is going to be less waste, I can't tell you how much stuff a school throws out and it is perfectly good stuff, from new boxes of chalk and crayons, to new pads of paper to construction paper, to TVs and projectors. All this waste will go away, my family has personally seen all of this waste going on. This includes schools only being able to hire a specific number of teacher and so all the crappy ones as mentioned above would go away and be jobless. This also has an effect on the private schools in that they would have more students and more money to hire new teachers. Causing a demand for good teachers and even raising the salary rates of current and new teachers.
Now I know from my research that many of the teacher and school officials say that vouchers will cause children in public school to get a poor education, because they won't have enough money to keep the public system going, but I beg to differ. As long as the public education system will adapt to the times and not submarine themselves by holding on to the crappy teachers and keeping the loose financial ship they are running, they will do fine. The only people that need be worried by this system would be the lazy teachers that don't know what work means, that shouldn't be teaching our children anyways.
We also hear the argument of seperation of church and state, with kids having the option to go to a Catholic school or a private school being ran by a religious sect. Now, this is bogus, because the government cannot have a national religion, or endorse any one religion. What is going on is, the government is enabling the parents to decide where they want to send their child to school. If the parent wants to have their child learn religion, while at school, that doesn't mean that the government is creating a national religion.
The reason I am for private schooling, is because I have been in a private school. I have seen the children that graduate from this school and they are top notch. These kids are held to a higher standard than in public schools. If these schools don't produce intelligent kids, then they would fail as the free market allows, because the parents then wouldn't take their kids to school there and they wouldn't have enough money to keep their school running. Having been in public schools and seen the large ugly side of it and how it has brought our education down. I just cannot accept letting my children go to a public school. So, if I have the means to get my kids into private school, I will do so.
Next time you see a flyer from your school see how many spelling errors you get? You'll be amazed, and these are the people teaching our kids.